Bewertung
4,0
Gut · von 5 Sternen
Edge Clear LLC Erfahrungen
4,0von 5 · Gut
Nicht beansprucht Beanspruchen Keine Antwort der Firma
Stimmen
22
6 in den letzten 12 Monaten
Handelskammer
77%
Anteil 5-Sterne-Bewertungen
Bewertungen (22)
6 in 12 MonatenIhre Stimme
Erfahrung zu Edge Clear LLC schreiben
FuturesByMets
Verifizierte Bewertung
They answer consumer calls!!
This has been an amazing broker to work with and they pick up the phone when call for Help.
0
Lene Mortensen
Verifizierte Bewertung
They encouraged me to re-enter positions, then liquidated me again — read this before you fund
They encouraged me to re-enter positions, then liquidated me again — read this before you fund I want to save other traders the experience I just had with EdgeClear. Liquidation #1 — I acted immediately, it made no difference When EdgeClear flagged a margin deficiency I responded immediately and initiated a wire transfer. I communicated this clearly to their team. Despite acting in good faith and with urgency, they liquidated my position anyway before the funds arrived. They later refunded the commissions — a quiet acknowledgment that the situation was not as clean as they now claim. The support that followed — vague, slow, and ultimately harmful After the first liquidation I was in contact with two of their team members, Max and Niko. Their messages strongly implied my situation would be reviewed, that I should re-enter my previous positions, and that they would work with me from there to remedy the situation. I followed that guidance in good faith. Any trader reading those messages would have done exactly the same. Liquidation #2 — they pointed me back into the market and then pulled the rug I rebuilt my positions as their team had encouraged me to do. Then EdgeClear liquidated me again. A second liquidation within 48 hours, on positions I had re-entered at their own staff's direct encouragement. No warning. No phone call. No chance to act. Just gone. Let that sink in: their team guided me back into the market, and then liquidated me without warning on those same positions. The CEO's response — a masterclass in deflection I escalated to the CEO, Morad Askar, expecting leadership and a genuine review. What I received was a carefully constructed email that reframed every single failure as my own decision. The encouraging messages from his staff? Completely unaddressed. The fact that I re-entered based on their guidance? Described as me simply "choosing" to re-enter. Every loss, every outcome — pinned cleanly on me. This is not a CEO who investigates and owns his team's mistakes. This is a CEO who writes airtight corporate emails and closes the door. The bottom line for US traders EdgeClear will enforce their margin policies to the letter when it costs you money. But when their own team's communications encourage you to take on risk and then that risk is liquidated without warning — do not expect the same precision in accountability. You will get silence when you need guidance, encouragement when it suits them, and a polished deflection email when you ask for answers. If your broker's integrity and support quality matter to you — and in fast-moving futures markets they absolutely should — think very hard before funding an account here.
0
Mike
Verifizierte Bewertung
EdgeClear has admitted in writing that…
EdgeClear has admitted in writing that they “mistakenly converted all USD to EUR” in my account without authorization. This is not disputed. Following this: They confirmed a financial impact caused by their own internal action They provided multiple inconsistent explanations of the same event They offered a settlement conditional on me not filing a complaint and removing my review After I refused, they terminated all communication and closed the case At the time of writing: The matter remains unresolved I have not accepted their settlement Funds remain in dispute This conduct raises serious concerns regarding: handling of client funds internal controls and supervision transparency and record access dispute resolution practices The case has now been formally submitted to: the National Futures Association the Commodity Futures Trading Commission including documentation of: potential breaches of CFTC customer fund rules supervisory failures and issues related to execution reliability For EU-based clients, this also raises concerns under: MiFID II (best execution and conduct of business) GDPR (access to communication records) The most concerning part is not the initial error — it is how the firm handled it: admitted mistake attempted to control escalation then cut off communication entirely Anyone considering this broker should carefully evaluate how disputes are handled if something goes wrong.
0
Von Sport
Verifizierte Bewertung
Headline
Headline: WARNING: 50% of my account wiped by platform freezes and unauthorized fees! Rating: ⭐☆☆☆☆ Stay far away from this broker! They claim to be a top-tier US futures firm, but they operate like a scam. I have lost nearly 50% of my total account balance—not due to trading, but due to their systemic failures and predatory fees. 1. The "Off-Switch" Platform (Market Manipulation): The platform froze repeatedly during active trading. It is extremely suspicious that the system "glitches" exactly when the market moves, only to miraculously start working again the moment you lodge a complaint. It feels like they are flipping a switch to prevent you from managing your trades. My stop-loss was ignored multiple times because of these freezes, leading to massive, unnecessary losses. 2. Unauthorized "Double" Currency Conversion: I funded my account in USD and traded in USD. Yet, they performed an unauthorized conversion of my entire balance into EUR and then back to USD for a withdrawal. They admitted in writing that converting the full balance was unnecessary, yet they still charged me $1600 in fees and predatory exchange spreads. This is pure theft disguised as a "technical requirement." 3. Total Lack of Professionalism: To lose 50% of your capital to a broker's technical incompetence and hidden fees is a disgrace. When confronted, they offered a "partial credit" instead of a full refund for their admitted mistakes. This is not a legitimate trading environment; it’s a trap for international investors. Final Verdict: If you have $10,000 or $100,000, do not put a single cent here. They will bleed you dry with "system freezes" and unauthorized currency games. I am filing a formal report with the NFA and CFTC regarding this market manipulation and theft of funds.
0
Orhan Jurat
Verifizierte Bewertung
Support is lightning-fast and…
Support is lightning-fast and expert—issues fixed in minutes, and truly personalized help. Best service in futures trading.
0
Die Akte
Alternativen zu Edge Clear LLC
Handelskammer-Ranking →Häufige Fragen zu Edge Clear LLC
Ist Edge Clear LLC seriös?
Für Edge Clear LLC liegen bisher 22 öffentliche Bewertungen vor (4,0 von 5) — für ein abschließendes Urteil ist die Datenlage noch dünn. Zur Einordnung: der Firmensitz (325 W HURON ST, 60654 Chicago, US) ist öffentlich dokumentiert, Kontaktdaten liegen offen. Prüfen Sie zusätzlich Impressum und Vertragsbedingungen.
Wo hat Edge Clear LLC seinen Sitz?
Edge Clear LLC hat seinen Sitz in 325 W HURON ST, 60654 Chicago, US. Die Angabe stammt aus öffentlichen Quellen und dem Impressum.
Welche Alternativen zu Edge Clear LLC gibt es?
Die bestbewerteten Anbieter in der Branche Handelskammer sind Forindex (3,3 von 5), SKINS-TABLE (4,3 von 5). Das vollständige Ranking mit allen Anbietern finden Sie in der Branchenübersicht auf erfahrungen.app.
Ist das Profil von Edge Clear LLC beansprucht?
Nein. Das Profil von Edge Clear LLC ist öffentlich, aber nicht vom Unternehmen beansprucht. Deshalb kann Edge Clear LLC hier nicht auf Bewertungen antworten. Die Firma kann das Profil kostenlos beanspruchen.
Antwortet Edge Clear LLC auf Bewertungen?
Edge Clear LLC lässt Bewertungen unbeantwortet. Keine Antwort innerhalb von 30 Tagen.
Kann Edge Clear LLC negative Bewertungen löschen lassen?
Nein. erfahrungen.app löscht, versteckt oder verkauft keine Bewertungen — auch nicht für verifizierte Unternehmen. Firmen können öffentlich antworten, aber Kritik bleibt stehen.
Wir löschen keine Bewertungen.
Auch nicht für Geld. Unclaimed ist fair. Claimed gibt das Mikrofon — nicht den Radiergummi.